In Emerging Markets Series of DFA Investment Trust Company (C -190/12), the European Court of Justice (ECJ) confirmed that investment funds based outside the European Union (EU) should benefit from the EU free movement of capital rule regarding investments in Europe. Thus, if an EU domestic investment fund can benefit from local income tax exemptions, then non-EU investment funds (e.g., U.S. or Canadian) investing in the EU should also be entitled to apply for such exemptions.
In Emerging Markets, a U.S. investment fund applied for a refund of withholding tax paid on dividends derived from Polish companies. The ECJ stated that U.S. investment funds are entitled to put themselves in a position similar to that of local funds. This means that under certain conditions non-EU investors may benefit from local tax preferences/exemptions.
In light of the relevant Polish regulations (which provide for income tax exemptions for domestic investment funds and funds based in the EU/EEA) and the tax information exchange agreement between Poland and U.S., the dividends paid to a U.S. investment fund should also be exempt from withholding tax in Poland.
The ECJ’s judgment in Emerging Markets provides a basis for non-EU investors to benefit from certain EU rules and to rely on tax preferences granted to EU/EEA entities. Therefore, if these investors have paid withholding tax on dividends derived from EU/EEA companies, they should consider whether certain tax preferences are available for investment funds in the country of residence of the companies paying the dividends (subject to any applicable time limits).
Canadian companies should also consider whether a refund of withholding tax would impact the foreign tax credit available in respect of any withholding tax previously paid and not refunded.
Additional information is available here.